FANGORIA® - Celebrating 30 Years of Horror 1979-2009 - Horror Movies, Music, Comics, Books, and more. Dedicated to the Preservation of All Things Horror...

FANGORIA.com
Home BLOGS Samuel Zimmerman I’m Bummed I RETURNed TO SLEEPAWAY CAMP

I’m Bummed I RETURNed TO SLEEPAWAY CAMP

I guess this entry is going to get kind of spoilerish, but sadly (not in a sarcastic way, this is actually really sad), RETURN TO SLEEPAWAY CAMP isn’t much worth your time anyway, so eh, read on.

SLEEPAWAY CAMP is rad. It’s that simple. It’s a modern slasher classic that I had no hesitation in returning to. It’s a case of, “I’m not sure what I want to watch, I’ll just throw on SLEEPAWAY CAMP,” or “Oh my God! You’ve never seen SLEEPAWAY CAMP?? We’re watching it right now!” How many times have you met someone who’s never seen it and then just got so excited at the prospect of making them see it and staring at their face at the end? It just contains a lot of nostalgic fun, and as far as late nights and friends go, it’s a good flick to love.

Was I stoked for RETURN TO SLEEPAWAY CAMP? Oh man, yes. As lovers of the original, my pal Gil and I diligently prepared for the highly anticipated viewing. And by diligently prepared…I mean we got food and a cheap case of “Milwaukee’s Best.”

So party time came—and barely left an impression.

The movie is all sorts of disappointment, and it’s hard to figure out where to begin. The central story is a huge problem, as no one in this film is likable. Not in the sense of “I’m fascinated by how bad of a person this character is,” but more like, “This is slightly excruciating to deal with.” The main victim of the bullying in this entry is Alan, a big-boned slob of a teen. The issue is that his torment is part of this odd vicious cycle where the kids making fun seem like assholes because of their awful pranks, but then Alan is such a little shit that he kind of deserves all the torture, and you’re never sure what came first. He himself pushes around kids smaller than him, doesn’t shower, doesn’t change his clothes and whines about the food he’s given. He also says, “Your ass stinks!” after every bit of abuse, and if I heard it one more time I was going to jump through the TV and kick the kid’s butt myself.

The best of the camp employees—Mickey, who works in the kitchen—is killed off all too quickly, as he’s pretty hilarious, and the only character we’re left with that we like is Ronnie, played by Paul DeAngelo from the original. Our love of Ronnie isn’t really a love for him, though; it’s a love for: 1. His awwwful acting; 2. The nostalgia he represents; 3. The phenomenal, ultra-amazing Guido Long Island pompadour/afro hair he’s got going on; 4. How buff he is and how he complements his buffness with stringy tank tops that are definitely from the actor’s own closet and probably date back to around the time the original SLEEPAWAY CAMP was made; and 5. How short his shorts are.

Vincent Pastore (“Big Pussy” from THE SOPRANOS) also shows up and is moderately entertaining, but mainly annoying as he spends most of the movie making verbal love to his pet bird. Isaac Hayes is in it. I don’t know why. He must have been hella bored when they offered him this, because there is literally no reason for him to appear, except to get viewers saying, “Oh man! It’s Chef from SOUTH PARK, playing a chef at a camp!” That’s not funny in the first place, and if you’re amused by that notion, I don’t want to be your friend. Hayes has about four scenes, doesn’t get offed and just kind of disappears into the background. They should’ve spent their money on anything else besides him, as a lot of the film is of not-so-high quality. There’s another counselor who’s sympathetic to Alan and serves as a red herring for the murders. She’s not a bad character; she just serves her function and doesn’t go anywhere.

In fact, the whole movie doesn’t go anywhere. It’s just some wacky kills, only one of which (the bunk bed) is actually great; silly cameos that don’t amount to anything (Ricky shows up, once again played by Jonathan Tiersten, and barely does anything except show off his cool hairstyle and look like he’s in a band, which of course he is in real life) and the lamest, most anticlimactic ending ever. Here we go into spoiler territory…

SPOILER ALERT!

The killer is Angela, a.k.a. Felissa Rose. Oh shit—really?! Yes. Surprised? You shouldn’t be. Her return is hinted at constantly as she walks around the whole movie in the silliest disguise ever (a cop uniform, a rubber nose, a fake beard and a voice simulator), and whether the movie is shooting for ultra-camp, humorous schlock or whatever, it still sucks. After the big reveal, the thing just ends. What? What the hell is that?! There could’ve been another 20 minutes. There’s a plethora of people left to kill and a whole lot of a lame movie to make up for. Instead, we get Angela recreating her famous maniacal face from the first film’s ending, except this time it’s not menacing, it just kind of looks like when one of your drunken friends does a bad impression of it.

If I seem bitter, it’s because I had high hopes, and I wanted to be super-happy and have an ultra-fun RETURN TO SLEEPAWAY CAMP. So, bottom line, just watch the original for the thousandth time.

And eat some pistachios, ’cause I really like them now.

And read BALTIMORE: OR, THE STEADFAST TIN SOLDIER AND THE VAMPIRE by Mike Mignola and Christopher Golden. It’s the best book I’ve read in quite some time, and I really can’t recommend it enough.

Terrifyingly Gnarly,
Sam
 

14 Comments

  1. RTSC = PILE OF SHIT. PERIOD. Wanna see a funny review? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzTR_0LZnWA Deadpit Radios Creepy's Crappy Movie Reviews. "This movie is so bad I can't even begin to describe how bad it is." said the Creepy Kentuckian from Deadpit.com
  2. Dude, you're right. it SUCKED. hardcore too. not just "not great" but totally suckage.
  3. You are seriously my hero. Sleepaway Camp is defintiely one of my all time favorite movies ever created. However, the Return was defintiely dissappointing. I seriously almost shut it off during the paintball scene. You shouldnt feel like you want to cry for one of the characters in a slasher film. And i couldnt even find one of those ridiculous lines to use on a regular basis, such as "hey bobbery bob. hey, hey bobbery bob" However, I must say, the cameos were great. Ronnie cracks me up and i love how Ricky shows up for no apparent reason.
  4. You are seriously my hero. You took my thoughts straight out of my head and put them in words. Sleepaway Camp is by far one of my favorite movies ever created. And the Return was definitely disappointing. I couldnt even find one of those moments in the movie to quote on a regular basis... like,"ain't ya loony toons?!"
  5. IMO Fango is actually getting better. The new site rocks fucking hard. Sure I dont agree with all the reviews but Ive learned which guys I agree with and stick with reading their stuff. The guys I think suck ass I just dont bother to read anymore. And now that we can comment like this it kinda evens things out for shit reviews anyway. I also like their new review thing where we can send in reviews and they put them on the front page, and Im gonna send some in.
  6. As far as accusations of conflict of interests go, I think that's a little silly. I mean, not one person reviews everything, there's plenty of reviewers all with different tastes and opinions so yea, some were stoked on a movie like WICKED LAKE. I definitely didn't love it. And besides, all in all, I'm just a kid with a blog. I don't really have any ties or networking or connections to be loyal to or vindictive against. What I meant about the charm of the original, was that in the first, it felt like they were trying. So even if it was campy, there was a heart to it.
  7. Fango is really going down the tubes. So off about so many flicks. Dude, the film is just like the original. Its a campy film and wasn't trying to "charm" you. and why was there such a big writeup in the mag?
  8. I have to agree with Sam. I wanted to love this film so much. I mean, the first Sleepaway Camp is classic. It deserved a better sequel than the ones provided without Hiltzik/Rose attached. But the movie sucked. Flat out sucked. The characters were brutal as you couldn't really like anyone. Additionally, the disguise on Angela was absolutely retarded. You'd have to be an idiot to go the 80 minutes without knowing the ending already. The only thing I can really offer that wasn't in the review is to watch through the credits for something extra. It at least explains how Angela stole the cop's identity...
  9. Oh I personally don't care how you get the book. My incentive definitely wasn't an amazon pimp, just a recommendation. I haven't seen Satan's Playground, definitely cannot subscribe to us here at Fango having a vendetta against Sleepaway, and sure as shit don't have a jealousy streak. I wanted to love it as much as you guys seem to, and I definitely didn't hate it because of the lack of modern horror cliches, I hate Saw editing. My point was, the movie was just bad - without the charm of the original. It felt like they could've gone so much farther and after such a long wait, didn't deliver.
  10. yeah, seems to be a lot of "conflict of interest" reviewers and stuff going on at Fango. That they gave the movie WICKED LAKE such high marks and coverage before it came out blows me away. Sadly, I cannot rely on Fango's coverage or criticisms anymore to gauge whether I want to see a movie or not. They used to be in tune with things, but have gotten waaaaaaaaaaaaay off track anymore. Sad but true. I enjoyed RETURN TO SLEEPAWAY CAMPE immensely, it wasn't bad at all, and eons better than crap that Fango seems to pimp out for their advertisers...
  11. Are we at a point where a flick like Return gets dissed because it didn't play by today's cliche horror movie rules? It had the guts to take us back to when interesting campy storytelling was more important than flashy editing and Jigsaw's latest game. Oh well, If Fango would rather try to pimp out films like Satan's Playground and diss films like Return then obviously it's all motivated by bullturd and selfishly jealous greed. No wonder why the readers have dwindled. Maybe you should start your review of Tomaselli's latest now and talk about how groundbreaking the writing is. Then if it ever gets made in 10 or 20 years we'll already know how amazing it is.
  12. Return had the balls to make a slasher movie like it was the 80's again, when we actually liked slasher movies. Yet Gingol and his boys didn't give Satan's Playground a crap review even though that flick was pure nonsense. Instead they'd rather attack the kind of movie that the people who grew up on Fangoria love. Yes, we love slasher movies. Yes we loved Sleepaway Camp. And yes, Return was a much needed old-school Return and a damn good time at that.
  13. Wow, somebody at Fango has a personal vendetta against this flick. 2 horrible reviews in 2 weeks. I guess one just wasn't enough. Didn't one of the reviewers, Michael Gingol try to write a script for Dante Tomaselli's latest attempt? What ever happened to that? That was 5 years ago now. Maybe he'd rather spend time trashing the latest Sleepaway Camp because he never got their film off the ground. If you've seen any of Tomaselli's films, it's not very hard to see why they can't find the funding.
  14. Haha, this is more "click through to Amazon and buy stuff so we can make money" than review. Shameless. I'm getting that book from the library, sucker!

Add Comment